Not amateur radio
MeshCore and Meshtastic compared
Two LoRa meshes that route differently: what each does, and the trade-offs.
Not amateur radio
Two LoRa meshes that route differently: what each does, and the trade-offs.
Meshtastic and MeshCore both move short messages over LoRa radios with no internet in between, and both use the same radio ideas (LoRa for mesh networks). They differ in how a message finds its way and which devices relay it. The table sticks to what each project's own documentation says about itself.
| Meshtastic | MeshCore | |
|---|---|---|
| Broadcasts and group messages | managed flooding: a node that hears a new packet may rebroadcast it after a short random delay, but stays quiet if a neighbor already did | group channels have no defined path, so they flood; repeater administrators can limit flood traffic |
| Direct messages | once a node learns which neighbor gives a working route, it addresses the message to that relay instead of letting every neighbor rebroadcast | the first message floods, a delivery report brings back the repeaters it crossed, and later messages carry that path so only matching repeaters retransmit |
| When a path fails | falls back to flooding if the relay does not respond | retries on the old path, then by default resets it and floods on the last retry |
| Who relays | depends on the role chosen in the device settings; a plain client rebroadcasts only when no other node has | companions never repeat; repeaters do, and room servers only if switched on |
| Roles | several, chosen in settings | companion, repeater and room server, by firmware |
| Hop limit | counted down in a 3-bit field in the packet header | the FAQ gives a firmware maximum of 64 hops |
| Privacy | channels share a key, payloads are encrypted and headers are not; direct messages use the recipient's public key | adverts carry a signed public key; packets carry a MAC and encrypted payload |
Read the details in Managed flooding, Device roles and Path routing.
Both are configured with LoRa bandwidth, spreading factor and coding rate. Meshtastic bundles them into named modem presets. The MeshCore documentation describes its radio presets as community suggestions that apps fetch, and says you may choose other settings if they comply with local rules. See Meshtastic and the rules for the rules side.